 |
A career-spanning review in the style of Piero Scaruffi |
Larkin’s Classics (2016) – 6.5/10
Super Dusty (2017) – 5/10
Super Sweet (2017) – 6/10
Super Sexy (2018) – 6/10
Super Bouncy (2019) – 5/10
Super Lonely (2019) – 7/10
I’m Good How are You (2020) – 3/10
BoyTimeBand, a pop group formed in Victoria, British Colombia by vocalists Adonis Johnson and Larkin Wallbank-Hart (as well as the elusive producer Sam), debuted in 2017 with the awful single “Town Square”. At the time, Larkin has already released two excellent singles, collected on Larkin’s Classics (2016): the infectious, Caribbean-tinged swing of “Freaky Fresh”, and the ridiculous house-inspired “The Cat Fell Down”. Both songs unleash his extraordinary talent for pairing irresistible hooks with absurd lyrics to create maximal amusement.
Super Dusty (2017) feels exactly like what it is: a group of high schoolers fooling around with audio software. The production never achieves the styles it emulates, only hints at them; the lyrics are rarely funny, only eyebrow-raising. “Care Bear City” boasts a celestial hyper-pop beat but ends up going nowhere. “Love at First Fight” has its dreamy moments but can’t find a melody to settle on. Songs like “Gospel to My Car”, “Dance with Me” and “Deep Sea” reach new levels of vapidity, with the two “personalities” simply muttering random phrases over elementary instrumentals for several minutes.
Occasionally the confusion transforms into accidental brilliance: “Grab my Cat” (with Adonis’ sensual vocals and a stomach-churning chorus) and “Big House” (club beat with a Captain Beefheart-esque accordion) are beyond puzzling, bordering on Lynchian horror. “I Feel So Close” is the exception to the rule, pairing a skittering, martial drum with a radiant, matutinal chorus; the song also features one of Larkin’s most evocative lines (“The cats are making out / In the alley tonight”). The piano ballad “Folded Mattress” offers some intrigue with its strange melody, and the closing track, “Move Your Hips”, premieres the band’s trademark multi-phase arrangement. But it’s too little, too late. The boys don’t really know how to make a proper song yet.
Later that year, the band released Super Sweet. With only four songs (including one cover), the group exchanges distracted quantity for focused quality. “10 I See”, despite its patently lame refrain, is nonetheless significantly more memorable and fluid than most of Dusty. “The Girls in the Country”, with its infernal banjo and goofy vocal manipulations, is pure foolishness. “Movie Star” is built on a single refrain (“I’m a movie star”), repeated ad nauseum over a stressful alternation between club beat and sinister ambience. For better or worse, this song effectively reinvents Pink Floyd’s “Bike” for the internet age.
Four more songs appear on Super Sexy (2018), where the band properly introduces their melancholy side (“Beautiful Flame”). “Young Love”, another schizophrenic song whose misty, tragic verse switches into an epileptic frenzy (“Yummy, yummy in my tummy!”) is perhaps the first towering achievement of the collective's career. The aggressive mumble-rap “Bad Boy” and the disgusting “Cheated on Your Wife” demonstrate how far they’ve come from their pointless debut.
Super Bouncy (2019) emulates the pop music of the day. “My Wife” parodies every radio hit of the late twenty-teens, while “Access” parodies Drake in particular. “Our First Time” features sitar and flute over an AWOLNATION “Sale”-esque beat. “Christmas Love” imitates Travis Scott’s trap with an eerie atmosphere. Unfortunately, in refining their songcraft they greatly dampen their charming, wacky energy; compared to the debut, the music is now eminently listenable but contains none of the highlights.
Super Lonely (2019), the band’s longest and most ambitious album, is their masterpiece. Not only has the production become far more polished, but the two charismatic vocalists manage to find an equilibrium of personality: by largely funneling Larkin’s role into the hooks (where he seems most comfortable), Adonis’ sincerer nature now adds a gravitas to the entire tracklist, contributing to an overall “professionalism” not present before.
With this new confidence, they lay down some of the strongest tracks of their career: the chilling and dreamy “Over the Harbour” soars like a drone above the city lights; the smooth, erotic, and shocking R&B of “Not Selfish” rivals Frank Ocean or D’Angelo; the nocturnal pulse and timeless refrain of “Marshgello” boasts Larkin’s most effortless rap verse; “Lonely Interlude” moves from a hazy, ambiguous ballad into a distorted and epileptic drop, from there morphing into nightmarish hallucinations. “Mine Games” harks back to the old days of Larkin’s domineering madness; a zany and stylish beat, mindless chatter, earth-shattering switch-ups, and a magnificent sax solo make this song more than worthy of Larkin’s Classics.
It is, however, Adonis whose persona now looms over the proceedings. His is an obsessive, loitering spirit, with a hint of tragedy – although always boyish enough to be dismissed for a laughable hook. He intones the celestial and moody “Stars” with the tremendously romantic line “I love you, forever” while the others make a ridiculous show; he brings down the house on the hard rocking “Cutie” and drones hypnotically over the intensely psychedelic “Recorded Overdose”. He pens his personal, tragic manifesto on the otherwise generic “What He Wants” (“Adonis wants to love”).
There are weak points, however: “On This Love Sack” regresses into the frustrating aimlessness of Dusty; “Little Old Sammy” never comes to fruition (its hilarious chorus notwithstanding); “High in Love” ranks among their most passable songs; and, despite its dramatic pretense and occasional catharsis, the closing track “I’ll Still Wait” does nothing to justify its fifteen-minute length.
Between the band’s slow, taciturn soul and the number of minor tracks, the album is difficult to stomach in a single sitting. Nevertheless, its moments of convergence are worth replaying long after most other pop music has been forgotten.
Larkin is nowhere to be found on I’m Good, How Are You (2020), an aggressively boring album that consists of Adonis whining over leftover beats. It is an injustice to the name of BoyTimeBand, destined to be no-listener music.
Best songs:
1. Young Love
2. Lonely Interlude
3. Movie Star
4. Mine Games
5. Not Selfish
6. I Feel So Close
7. Grab My Cat
8. Marshgello
9. Stars
10. Care Bear City